With nearly $1 billion in career sales and recognition as a two-time Top 100 Sales Associate Worldwide with Sotheby's International Realty, Jay Pennypacker brings an extraordinary level of expertise to Arizona's luxury real estate market. His remarkable journey combines the precision and discipline of a former PGA Golf Professional with the sophisticated understanding of Scottsdale and Paradise Valley's most prestigious communities.
As a distinguished member of the 1992 NCAA Championship Men's Golf Team at the University of Arizona and current Executive Committee Member of the Arizona Golf Association, Jay offers unparalleled insights into the Valley's exclusive golf and country club communities. His decade-plus membership at The Estancia Club and comprehensive understanding of premier developments provide clients with exceptional access to lifestyle opportunities that extend far beyond the transaction.
Jay's approach to luxury real estate is defined by meticulous attention to detail, anticipatory service, and strategic execution. His phenomenal memory and remarkable listening skills enable him to consistently exceed client expectations, creating seamless, elevated real estate experiences. Whether orchestrating the sale of a prestigious estate, guiding the acquisition of a sophisticated golf property, or expanding an investment portfolio, Jay's precision-driven methodology ensures every aspect of the transaction is handled with exceptional care and expertise.
As a proud father of two sons—Jake, an ASU graduate employed by the State of Arizona, and Ty, a student-athlete pursuing collegiate golf at Aurora University—Jay understands the importance of family, community, and legacy in real estate decisions. This personal insight, combined with his professional excellence, creates a unique advisory approach that resonates with distinguished clients seeking not just a property, but a lasting foundation for their lifestyle aspirations.
Where’s the best course to tee off at sunrise? Which Scottsdale steakhouse serves the perfect tomahawk? And what’s the ideal wine pairing for a prime cut from the Valley’s top butcher? Just ask Jay.
From fairways to fine dining, he’s your go-to guide for the ultimate Arizona lifestyle.
Beyond the Transaction
Living and working in Arizona provides an unparalleled lifestyle, one that blends breathtaking natural beauty with world-class amenities. Jay's deep-rooted connection to the Valley allows him to guide clients toward more than just a home; he helps them discover the essence of Arizona living. Whether it’s securing a property within a prestigious golf community, navigating the dynamic luxury market, or uncovering hidden gems, Jay ensures his clients find a space that enhances their lifestyle.
With an insider’s knowledge of Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, and the surrounding areas, Jay understands that real estate isn’t just about transactions, it’s about creating a life filled with opportunity. From championship golf courses and exclusive country clubs to vibrant dining, outdoor adventures, and a year-round active lifestyle, the Valley offers something for everyone. Jay’s expertise extends beyond the sale, ensuring his clients not only find the perfect home but also embrace the Arizona way of life.
Receive up-to-date local real estate
news and AZ lifestyle updates.
My top 5
favorite things
Golf
Beyond his achievements as a member of the 1992 NCAA Championship Men's Golf Team and former PGA Golf Professional, Jay's passion for golf extends into every aspect of his life. His intimate knowledge of Arizona's premier golf communities comes from lived experience—as a 10+ year member of The Estancia Club and social member at DC Ranch Country Club. This firsthand expertise translates directly to his unparalleled ability to match discerning clients with the perfect golf community lifestyle that aligns with their aspirations.
Learn More
DC Ranch Village Health Club and Spa
One of my most favorite spots for hot yoga and fitness classes… offering state-of-the-art facilities, a luxurious spa, and a tranquil atmosphere, it's the ideal escape for all things wellness!
Learn More
HIKING
Arizona's dramatic landscapes provide the perfect backdrop for Jay's appreciation of the outdoors. His favorite hiking trails traverse Scottsdale's McDowell Sonoran Preserve and Paradise Valley's Camelback Mountain, offering both challenging terrain and breathtaking views. This intimate knowledge of the region's natural treasures allows Jay to guide clients toward properties that provide not just luxury living, but also access to Arizona's magnificent outdoor lifestyle—a perspective that only comes from someone who truly experiences it.
Learn More
TRAVEL
Jay's global perspective has been shaped by thoughtful exploration of world-class destinations. From historic European wine regions to exclusive coastal retreats, his travels inform his approach to luxury real estate by recognizing the universal elements of exceptional living. This worldview enhances his ability to understand the sophisticated needs of international clients and those seeking properties that reflect the highest global standards—bringing a wealth of inspiration to each client relationship.
Learn More
COOKING
The art of fine cooking represents Jay's appreciation for craftsmanship, precision, and the joy of creating memorable experiences. His understanding of premium kitchen design and functionality comes from practical experience, allowing him to evaluate luxury properties with a connoisseur's eye for culinary spaces. This passion translates directly to his ability to identify homes where entertaining and daily living harmonize perfectly—recognizing that for many discerning clients, the kitchen is truly the heart of an exceptional home.
Learn More